4 min read

The Procurement Death Zone: Why Canadian Cleantech Startups Fall Between Pilot and Purchase Order

Why does Canada convert less than half the Series B companies of the US, Israel, or Australia? We are funding the invention and starving the commercialization. Here's how founders, investors, and governments can fix it.
The Procurement Death Zone: Why Canadian Cleantech Startups Fall Between Pilot and Purchase Order
Photo by Mike Markov on Unsplash

In mountaineering, the death zone begins at 8,000 metres. Everest’s summit is 8,848. That last stretch is where most people don’t come back. 

I think of the climb from pilot to full scale deployment as Canadian cleantech's most dangerous zone. 

Last week I joined the Foresight 50 Showcase in Vancouver, where James Chepyha of Emergex Venture Partners opened with a hard look at why Canada converts so few seed-stage companies into Series B companies. The number circulating is 8.4%. Compared with the 2025 figures for the USA, Israel and even Australia, the rate is less than half.

I was invited to join a panel discussion on this topic, and here are some of my thoughts from a Canadian entrepreneur's perspective...

Sell before you're ready

I learned the most about this at NanoH2O, a California startup that became one of the water industry’s top success stories (exit 2014 to LG, $200M). Early on, demand outpaced our production ramp. As soon as our membranes met customer specifications, we began shipping against a strong order book. When we won our largest contract, it required scaling output to 800 elements a week, roughly 4x our initial run rate. We worked closely with the customer to align delivery schedules and pricing, and that collaborative approach helped us earn their long-term partnership as we scaled.

Canadian cleantech founders, many of us engineers-turned-entrepreneurs, want products perfect before we sell. Our successful southern neighbours just go for it. We need to build businesses not just technologies.

Innovation committees are where startups slowly freeze 

Most large organizations want to be seen as innovative while minimizing spend on it. Their status quo makes reliable cash. Innovation committees are built to run pilots, not to buy, and a startup can sit in “innovation theatre” for years with no budget owner and no path to contract.

My battle scar advice to founders:

  • Run only paid, scoped pilots with pre-agreed success criteria and a named budget owner.
  • Find a 1:1 champion, and get air cover from the CEO and CFO. Sometimes that means working quietly, almost black-ops style, to climb around innovation committees.

It’s a leadership problem

Startup research consistently shows the top two reasons companies fail are 1) running out of cash and a 2) lack of product-market fit. I argue both trace back to leadership. The leader didn’t act on cash in time. The leader didn’t listen for product feedback. The leader let their biases or ego win instead of admitting a problem, owning it, and dealing with it. The leader let the company fall in the death zone between pilot and full sale.

Mike Dixon speaking into a microphone on stage during a panel discussion at the Foresight 50 Showcase in Vancouver, gesturing with his hands while seated between two other panelists.
Speaking last week at the 2026 Foresight 50 Showcase in Vancouver

What acquirers actually pay for

When Synauta was acquired by Gradiant (which reached a $1B valuation in 2023 and $2B in 2026), the buyer wasn’t just paying for technology. They needed to see the customers who bought, renewed and trusted us. That means real sales, a healthy pipeline, and good sales discipline. Most acquirers want to see that the machine can keep running when the founders step away. Series B investors want the same thing: a proven sales process they can crank the handle on.

Where I’d push back on the tax proposals

I support what James proposes, but I’m not convinced taxing ESOP options at exit rather than exercise moves the needle as much as his three other suggestions.

For employees who stay with a startup/company until an exit, exercise and payout happen simultaneously, so they already have the cash on hand to pay the tax. Changing the tax timing mostly helps employees who leave before a liquidity event.

My view is that we should incentivize people to stay:

  • If a company lets someone go because they fit the early stage better than the late stage, deferring their tax bill until an exit is fair.
  • If an employee chooses to leave, especially to join a foreign competitor, they shouldn't get that tax break.

The main exception is when a Series B is funded by US or overseas investors that triggers immediate tax payments. In that specific scenario, James’s proposal is spot on.

The angel tax credit is a different story and a bigger lever. While more angel capital doesn’t guarantee companies will reach Series B, it creates a larger pool of funded startups, giving more of them a shot at scaling.

What governments could do

Governments could be a first customer, not just a funder. Grants aren’t filling the gap, and CVCA reported declines in pre-seed and seed deal flow in Q4 2025.

I suggest governments give homegrown startups a “strategic free kick”: the first pilot skips lengthy procurement that is designed for established large companies, and subsequent sales go through the normal process. Project risks and finances should be managed for the pilot to protect taxpayer money and get the best bang for buck. 

The procurement mindset needs to shift from "hiding behind red tape to avoid accusations of favouritism" to “this creates jobs and strengthens the economy.”

However, the opportunity should not be a blank cheque, and the government should be ruthless at intake so only the best solutions are piloted. And, as mentioned, any second purchase goes through regular procurement channels. 

Should Series B be the goal?

One last question: do we really need to copy the US and chase more Series B companies in Canada? 

Maybe an economy fuelled by profitable, resilient, middle market companies is just as formidable as one powered by a small handful of Series B bets. High valuations make great headlines, but sustainable revenue pays the bills.

And, when public procurement forces cleantech startups to raise round after round just to survive the wait between pilot and purchase order, we aren't building a tech powerhouse, we're manufacturing unnecessary burn rate.

Comparison is the thief of joy, but for our startup ecosystem, it’s also the thief of focus.

Closing the loop

Founders: run only paid pilots.

Investors: guide entrepreneurs through the procurement death zone, don't just fund the burn.

Governments: buy pilots that contractually and conditionally lead to a full sale.

We keep funding the invention and starving the commercialization. Simply put, Canadians need to focus on building businesses, not just technologies. It’s time to get strong for the summit push!